It’s True: Research Shows Leaner Athletes Are Faster

Endurance sports, of course, tend to favor two related body characteristics:

  1. low body weight
  2. lean body composition (or a low body-fat level).

This is the case because endurance racing demands the ability to move economically so that a high work rate (or speed) can be sustained for a long time and a low body weight and lean body composition contribute to movement efficiency.

The advantages of being light and lean for endurance performance are so obvious that they hardly needed to be scientifically proven, but exercise scientists have gone out and proven them anyway, and the proof is interesting. Here are just a few examples.

  • Bale, Bradbury, and Colley 1986: Among 60 male runners, the fastest runners were the lightest and leanest. The heaviest, least lean runners were the slowest. And in this study, the average weight difference between the fast, average, and slow groups was just 11 pounds. The point? Just a few pounds make a big difference.
  • Knechtle et al. 2011: Body weight had a moderate effect on race times for Ironman® athletes, but body-fat percentage had a large effect on race times. Both body weight and body fat were more strongly correlated with race times, especially for run splits, than training variables like average weekly training time. The point? Your body composition matters more than how much you train.
  • A 1999 Spanish study: Performance in a flat cycling time trial is best predicted by a rider’s maximum power output, but performance in an uphill time trial is best predicted by the rider’s power-to-weight ratio. The point? If you plan to race going up, you’ll want your power-to-weight ratio to go up first.
  • Hecht et al. 2007: Researchers found that the average body-fat percentage among age-group (i.e., non-elite) participants in an Ironman triathlon was 17 percent for males and 27 percent for females. These values are lower than average for the general population, but much higher than the values seen in the pros. And sure enough, when the researchers matched body-fat percentages against finishing times, they found that the men and women with the leanest bodies were also the fastest. The point? Yes, even triathletes can improve their finish times by getting leaner.

Racing Weight 2nd Ed. RW2 96dpi 400x600p strokeRacing Weight is the proven weight-management program for endurance athletes. See what’s new in the new edition and then look for the book in your local bookstore; bike, running, or tri shop; or online.

Why Athletes Should Ignore Body Mass Index (BMI)

Racing Weight and Body Mass Index BMI for athletesBody mass index (BMI) has been in the news lately. It was put there put Katherine Flegal, a researcher on the epidemiology of obesity. Flegal and a few of her colleagues conducted a scientific review of past studies that had correlated body mass index with the risk of dying of various diseases. Their “meta-analysis” was published in the January 2013 edition of JAMA (the Journal of the American Medical Association). The reason it made news was that Flegal’s study reported that men and women who were classified as overweight (but not obese) by official BMI standards tended to live longer than people who were classified as normal weight.

What’s Wrong with This Picture?

Many strong opinions about this surprising finding were expressed. A number of Flegal’s fellow obesity experts dismissed it as an erroneous result of faulty methodology. So-called fat advocates hailed it as final proof of what they had known all along. As for me, when I read about the paper I merely felt glad that I had stopped giving credence to the BMI scale long before.

BMI, in case you don’t know, is a number that represents the relationship between a person’s height and weight. Since taller people tend to weigh more, BMI was created as a tool that people could use to determine whether they were too heavy for their height. The problem with BMI is that while it effectively neutralizes the influence of height on body weight, Body mass index makes no distinction between body fat and lean body mass. For example, a lean football player with a BMI of 25.5 and a couch potato with a huge beer belly and a BMI of 25.5 are both classified as overweight by the BMI scale, which defies common sense.

BMI vs. Body Composition

By ignoring body composition, BMI sacrifices a lot of predictive power in relation to health outcomes. In recent years, medical researchers have performed a number of studies comparing the effect of BMI versus that of body composition (or body fat percentage) on the risk for various diseases. The conclusion is always the same. While the effect of higher BMI on the risk for lifestyle diseases such as heart disease than normal-weight men and women is muddled, the connection between body fat percentage and disease risk is much stronger. In fact, heavier individuals with a low body fat percentage tend to be healthier and to live longer than skinnier individuals with a higher body fat percentage. In other words, body composition is a far better predictor of health and longevity than BMI. Doctors recently coined the term “normal weight obese” to categorize men and women who fall within the normal body weight range but have more than 30 percent body fat. Studies have found that normal weight obese individuals have the same levels of circulating inflammation markers—a major heart disease risk factor—as those who are technically obese.

Muscle vs. Fat

A second reason why lean men and women are healthier than skinny people with more fat hidden inside them has to do with muscle. Recent medical research has shown that muscle mass is as beneficial to health as excess body fat is damaging to health. Having a little extra muscle has been shown to increase metabolism, reduce insulin resistance and diabetes risk, increase bone density and lower the risk of osteoporosis, and more. Having a little extra muscle even increases longevity. A number of studies have found that, among elderly populations, those with the most muscle strength live the longest.

In addition to telling members of the general population more about their health than BMI does, body fat percentage tells endurance athletes more about their fitness than BMI does. Research has demonstrated that endurance athletes perform best at a body fat percentage that is close to the minimum they can attain through focused training and healthy eating. Regularly monitoring body fat percentage makes a lot of sense for endurance athletes. A 2 percent drop in body fat could easily correlate to a big leap forward in performance, even if your body weight—hence BMI—stays the same.

So if you aren’t yet tracking your body fat percentage, start. And if you are paying attention to headlines about BMI, stop!

Racing Weight 2nd Ed. RW2 96dpi 400x600p strokeRacing Weight is available in bookstores; bike, tri, and running shops; and online. See what’s new in this new edition of Racing Weight or order your copy today:

How Pro Athletes Manage Their Weight

The smartest way to manage your weight for endurance performance is to emulate the methods of the fastest men and women on the planet.

By Matt Fitzgerald

The leanest cyclists, runners, and triathletes are typically also the fastest endurance ones. This pattern holds even within the select ranks of the professionals. One study reported that in a small group of elite Ethiopian runners, all of whom were very lean and very fast, those with the least body fat had the best race times.

Genes account for a portion of the difference in body fat levels between individual endurance athletes. But there is a tendency among us age groupers to overestimate the importance of the genetic contribution to leanness in the pros. We like to think that the world-class men and women who were blessed with the right DNA can eat whatever they want without putting on body fat.

In fact, most of the top cyclists, runners, and triathletes work very hard at managing their weight and body composition for performance. What’s more, they tend to rely on the same methods to stay lean. And guess what? The very same methods of weight management that work so well for the world’s best endurance athletes are can help everyday competitors like us achieve our optimal racing weight too, even if that weight is a few pounds greater than the pros’.

I’ve spent a lot of time studying the diets and weight-management practices of world-class endurance athletes. In 2009 I collected the top five and linked them into a systematic program in my book, Racing Weight. Since then I’ve identified a sixth key practice and added it to the recently published second edition of Racing Weight. Let’s take a look at these six methods.

Step 1: Improve your diet quality

After graduating from the University of Wisconsin in 2007 as a five-time NCAA champion, Chris Solinsky moved to Portland, Ore., to run professionally for Nike. He also decided to improve his eating habits. Instead of adopting a diet with a name (e.g. vegan, paleo, gluten free) and lots of weird rules, he simply improved the overall quality of his diet in commonsense ways, eating more vegetables, fewer frozen pizzas, and so forth. As a result he lost several pounds and achieved a performance breakthrough, setting an American record of 26:59:60 for 10,000 meters in 2010.

Increasing the overall quality of your diet is the simplest and most effective way to shed excess body fat and move closer to your optimal racing weight. That means eating more of the six categories of high-quality foods—vegetables, fruits, nuts and seeds, lean meats and fish, whole grains, and dairy—and less of the four categories of low-quality foods—refined grains, fatty meats, sweets, and fried foods. In Racing Weight I present a unique scoring system that enables athletes to easily rate the quality of their diet and systematically increase it.

Step 2: Manage your appetite

At the height of his training for the Ironman World Championship each year, triathlon legend Peter Reid kept no food in his kitchen—none—so that he wouldn’t be tempted to overeat. It was an extreme measure, but Reid knew his ideal racing weight was 164 to 165 pounds (or 7-10 pounds below his natural off-season weight) and he knew that he could not reach his racing weight if he fully indulged his appetite. It’s hard to argue with the results: three victories and three runner-up finishes in Kona between 1998 and 2004.

Research conducted by Brian Wansink, author of Mindless Eating, and others has demonstrated that most people automatically eat more food than they need unless they take conscious steps to control their “food environment” and eat more mindfully. These measures do not need to include removing all of the food from your kitchen, but they may include removing all of the low-quality temptations from your kitchen and replacing your current dishes with smaller dishes on which you serve yourself slightly smaller portions.

Step 3: Balance your energy sources

The world’s best runners come from Kenya and Ethiopia. The diet of the typical East African runner is 76 to 78 percent carbohydrate. Compare that to the diet of the average American, which is only 48 percent carbohydrate. Research going all the way back to the 1960s has consistently shown that a high-carbohydrate diet best supports intensive endurance training. Unfortunately, the low-carb diet craze of the late 1990s and early 2000s has cast a long shadow, causing many age-group athletes to eat too little carbohydrate to properly support their training.

Actually, not every endurance athlete needs a high-carb diet. Carbohydrate needs are closely tied to training volume. The more you train, the more carbs you need. Use this table to determine the daily carbohydrate intake target that’s right for you.

Average Daily Training Time(Running and Other Activities) Daily Carbohydrate Target
30-45 minutes 3-4 g/kg*
46-60 minutes 4-5 g/kg
61-75 minutes 5-6 g/kg
76-90 minutes 6-7 g/kg
90 minutes 7-8 g/kg
>120 minutes 8-10 g/kg

* 1 kg = 2.2 lbs

Step 4: Monitor yourself

When Bradley Wiggins won the Tour de France in 2012 he weighed 158 pounds and had 4 percent body fat. Four years earlier, when he won his last Olympic gold medals as a track cyclist, Wiggins weighed 180 pounds and his body fat level was a few points higher. His slimming was a major factor in his Tour de France triumph, and he achieved that slimming in part by continuously monitoring his weight and body composition.

In business there’s an expression: “What gets measured gets managed.” If you’re trying to reduce your weight and body-fat percentage, it only makes sense to measure these things regularly. The pros do, and research has shown that nonathlete dieters who weigh themselves often lose more weight than those who avoid the scale. I recommend that all endurance athletes weigh themselves at least once a week and use a body fat scale such as the Tanita Ironman to estimate their body-fat percentage once every four weeks.

Step 5: Time your nutrition

A naturally big guy who once tipped the scales at 200 pounds, professional triathlete T.J. Tollakson stays lean by frontloading his daily energy intake in accordance with the dictum “eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince, and dinner like a pauper.”

With respect to weight management, when you eat is almost as important as what you eat. The most important times of the day to eat are in the morning and within an hour after workouts because calories eaten at these times are less likely to be stored as fat and more likely to be incorporated into muscle tissue and used for immediate energy needs.

Step 6: Train for racing weight

Nearly all professional endurance athletes train by what’s known as the Lydiard method, which entails doing a high volume of training, about 80 percent of it at low intensities, 10 percent at moderate intensities, and 10 percent at high intensities.

While a low-volume, high-intensity approach to training has gained popularity among age-group endurance athletes lately, it is not the most effective way to train for endurance performance or achieve a lean body composition. Research provides clear support for the Lydiard method that is used almost universally by the elites.

Obviously, few age groupers have the time, energy, or durability to train as much as the pros do, but that’s not the point. The point is to maintain a training volume that is close to your personal limit and to keep the intensity low for four out of every five workouts. If you do this you will burn far more calories and build greater aerobic fitness than you possibly could by doing the small volume of training you can handle if you go hard (or even moderately hard, as a majority of age groupers do) in most workouts.

When it comes to training and eating to attain your optimal racing weight, the best thing to do is the same thing you do in races: follow the pros!

Racing Weight 2nd Ed. RW2 96dpi 400x600p strokeRacing Weight is the proven weight-management program for endurance athletes. See what’s new in the new edition and then look for the book in your local bookstore; bike, running, or tri shop; or online.

Why Leaner Athletes Are Faster (It’s More Than Gravity)

Research, common sense, and race experience have shown that leaner athletes tend to be faster. Why? It’s not just gravity.

Gravity

It’s the most obvious reason. We’ve all felt the heaviness that comes with fatigue while running or riding uphill. Swimmers that have to move larger limbs get tired more quickly, too.

Competition for Oxygen

One of the most crucial underpinnings of endurance performance is the ability to deliver oxygen to the working muscles at a high rate. As body-fat levels go down, aerobic capacity goes up, because muscle has less competition from fat tissue for oxygen and fuel.

Heat Dissipation

The primary function of body fat, of course, is insulation. An athlete’s ability to dissipate heat is an important performance factor in all forms of long-distance racing. While this ability is partly a function of the ratio of body surface area to body volume, this ratio is smaller in bigger athletes. So excess body fat impedes heat dissipation. It’s easier to stay cool on a long ride on a hot summer day if you’re very lean.

Fat-Burning vs. Carb-Burning

Sure, heavier athletes have more mass to move, but body fat isn’t just dead weight. Fat is a metabolically active organ that affects exercise metabolism in important ways that are not yet fully understood. One thing we do know is that athletes with larger amounts of body fat burn less fat and more carbohydrate at lower exercise intensities. Since the body burns carbs during racing but can only store small amounts of carbs, less lean athletes will burn through their valuable carb stores before leaner athletes.

Inertia

Lighter cyclists can accelerate more efficiently. Good criterium riders are often smaller riders who can match surges in the race more quickly than others.

Swimmers with heavier limbs have to use more energy to move their arms and legs.

But small athletes are often at an advantage on flat courses. Why? Inertia and hydrodynamics.

Hydrodynamics

In swimming, the fastest athletes tend to be tall and rangy instead of broad. Their narrower bodies present less frontal area in the water, making them more hydrodynamic.

But Get This…

Excess fat hurts performance, but excess muscle is in fact even more detrimental because it is far more dense, which is why we’re as unlikely to see a muscle-bound Tour de France winner as an obese one.

But what constitutes excess muscle is very different from what constitutes excess body fat since muscle is the engine of movement whereas body fat makes no contribution to endurance performance beyond providing energy for low-intensity exercise. Even the skinniest runner carries enough body fat to fuel 24 hours of continuous exercise.

Too Much Fat Is Bad for Athletes in Many Ways

Not only are top-level athletes quite lean, but also body composition is an excellent predictor of performance at all levels of endurance sports.

Racing Weight 2nd Ed. RW2 96dpi 400x600p strokeRacing Weight is the proven weight-loss program for endurance athletes. See what’s new in the new edition and then look for the book in your local bookstore; bike, running, or tri shop; or online.

Hit Your Fastest Weight with the New Book Racing Weight

VeloPress announces the release of a new edition of the best-selling book on weight-loss for endurance athletes

Racing Weight 2nd Ed. RW2 96dpi 400x600p strokeBoulder, CO, USA — December 11, 2012 — Certified sports nutritionist and best-selling author Matt Fitzgerald has updated his proven weight-management program for athletes in the new second edition of Racing Weight: How to Get Lean for Peak Performance. Three out of four endurance athletes are concerned about their body weight because they know that excess fat hurts their performance. Now endurance athletes can hit their fastest race weight with the best-selling weight-loss plan for cyclists, triathletes, runners, and swimmers. Racing Weight, 2nd Ed. is now available in bookstores; bike, triathlon, and running stores; and online. Preview the book and find weight loss tips for athletes at this all-new website www.racingweight.com.

Being lean offers endurance athletes a powerful performance advantage. Among elites, studies have shown that the fastest athletes are the leanest. Lean athletes conserve energy, dissipate heat faster, and even gain more fitness from every workout. But dieting is dangerous for athletes, harming their training and actually worsening their fat-to-muscle ratio. Racing Weight is the comprehensive weight-management plan designed specifically for athletes.

Racing Weight is based on the latest science—and the best practices of elite athletes. Six simple steps will get athletes to their fastest weight. Athletes will estimate their off-season and race weights and begin the Racing Weight program to hit their numbers on the scale and on the race course. The Racing Weight plan shows athletes how to improve diet quality, manage appetite, balance energy sources, time meals and snacks, easily monitor weight and performance, and train to get—and stay—lean.

The new edition of Racing Weight offers improvements to practical tools that make weight-management easy. Fitzgerald’s no-nonsense Diet Quality Score improves diet without counting calories. A new chapter on Racing Weight superfoods suggests diet foods high in the nutrients athletes need for training. Supplemental strength training workouts can accelerate changes in body composition. Daily food diaries from 18 pro athletes reveal how the elites maintain an athletic diet while managing appetite.

Athletes know that every extra pound wastes energy and hurts performance. With Racing Weight, cyclists, triathletes, and runners have a simple weight-management program and practical tools to hit their fastest weight.

Racing Weight: How to Get Lean for Peak Performance
Matt Fitzgerald
6″ x 9″, 296 pp., $18.95, 9781934030998
Paperback with tables and illustrations throughout.

Matt Fitzgerald is the author of numerous books on running, triathlon, nutrition, and weight loss. He has been a contributor to Men’s Fitness, Men’s Health, Outside, Runner’s World, Bicycling, Running Times, Triathlete, Inside Triathlon, Women’s Running, and other fitness publications. Fitzgerald is a featured coach on Training Peaks, Active.com, and PEAR Sports. He is a certified sports nutritionist (CISSN) licensed by the International Society of Sports Nutrition. He lives and trains in San Diego, California. For more information, please visit mattfitzgerald.org.

VeloPress publishes training, nutrition, and history books on cycling, triathlon, and running. See more VeloPress books and download previews at www.velopress.com.

Media, marketing, and sales contact: Dave Trendler, VeloPress, dtrendler@competitorgroup.com Like VeloPress on Facebook: facebook.com/OfficialVeloPress | Follow VeloPress on Twitter @velopress

Racing Weight 2nd Ed. RW2 96dpi 400x600p strokeRacing Weight is a proven weight-management program for endurance athletes.

How The Pros Stay Lean

The smartest way to manage your weight for endurance performance is to emulate the methods of the fastest men and women on the planet.

By Matt Fitzgerald

The leanest cyclists, runners, and triathletes are typically also the fastest endurance ones. This pattern holds even within the select ranks of the professionals. One study reported that in a small group of elite Ethiopian runners, all of whom were very lean and very fast, those with the least body fat had the best race times.

Genes account for a portion of the difference in body fat levels between individual endurance athletes. But there is a tendency among us age groupers to overestimate the importance of the genetic contribution to leanness in the pros. We like to think that the world-class men and women who were blessed with the right DNA can eat whatever they want without putting on body fat.

In fact, most of the top cyclists, runners, and triathletes work very hard at managing their weight and body composition for performance. What’s more, they tend to rely on the same methods to stay lean. And guess what? The very same methods of weight management that work so well for the world’s best endurance athletes are can help everyday competitors like us achieve our optimal racing weight too, even if that weight is a few pounds greater than the pros’.

I’ve spent a lot of time studying the diets and weight-management practices of world-class endurance athletes. In 2009 I collected the top five and linked them into a systematic program in my book, Racing Weight. Since then I’ve identified a sixth key practice and added it to the recently published second edition of Racing Weight. Let’s take a look at these six methods.

Step 1: Improve your diet quality

After graduating from the University of Wisconsin in 2007 as a five-time NCAA champion, Chris Solinsky moved to Portland, Ore., to run professionally for Nike. He also decided to improve his eating habits. Instead of adopting a diet with a name (e.g. vegan, paleo, gluten free) and lots of weird rules, he simply improved the overall quality of his diet in commonsense ways, eating more vegetables, fewer frozen pizzas, and so forth. As a result he lost several pounds and achieved a performance breakthrough, setting an American record of 26:59:60 for 10,000 meters in 2010.

Increasing the overall quality of your diet is the simplest and most effective way to shed excess body fat and move closer to your optimal racing weight. That means eating more of the six categories of high-quality foods—vegetables, fruits, nuts and seeds, lean meats and fish, whole grains, and dairy—and less of the four categories of low-quality foods—refined grains, fatty meats, sweets, and fried foods. In Racing Weight I present a unique scoring system that enables athletes to easily rate the quality of their diet and systematically increase it.

Step 2: Manage your appetite

At the height of his training for the Ironman World Championship each year, triathlon legend Peter Reid kept no food in his kitchen—none—so that he wouldn’t be tempted to overeat. It was an extreme measure, but Reid knew his ideal racing weight was 164 to 165 pounds (or 7-10 pounds below his natural off-season weight) and he knew that he could not reach his racing weight if he fully indulged his appetite. It’s hard to argue with the results: three victories and three runner-up finishes in Kona between 1998 and 2004.

Research conducted by Brian Wansink, author of Mindless Eating, and others has demonstrated that most people automatically eat more food than they need unless they take conscious steps to control their “food environment” and eat more mindfully. These measures do not need to include removing all of the food from your kitchen, but they may include removing all of the low-quality temptations from your kitchen and replacing your current dishes with smaller dishes on which you serve yourself slightly smaller portions.

Step 3: Balance your energy sources

The world’s best runners come from Kenya and Ethiopia. The diet of the typical East African runner is 76 to 78 percent carbohydrate. Compare that to the diet of the average American, which is only 48 percent carbohydrate. Research going all the way back to the 1960s has consistently shown that a high-carbohydrate diet best supports intensive endurance training. Unfortunately, the low-carb diet craze of the late 1990s and early 2000s has cast a long shadow, causing many age-group athletes to eat too little carbohydrate to properly support their training.

Actually, not every endurance athlete needs a high-carb diet. Carbohydrate needs are closely tied to training volume. The more you train, the more carbs you need. Use this table to determine the daily carbohydrate intake target that’s right for you.

Average Daily Training Time

(Running and Other Activities)

Daily Carbohydrate Target
30-45 minutes 3-4 g/kg*
46-60 minutes 4-5 g/kg
61-75 minutes 5-6 g/kg
76-90 minutes 6-7 g/kg
90 minutes 7-8 g/kg
>120 minutes 8-10 g/kg

* 1 kg = 2.2 lbs

Step 4: Monitor yourself

When Bradley Wiggins won the Tour de France in 2012 he weighed 158 pounds and had 4 percent body fat. Four years earlier, when he won his last Olympic gold medals as a track cyclist, Wiggins weighed 180 pounds and his body fat level was a few points higher. His slimming was a major factor in his Tour de France triumph, and he achieved that slimming in part by continuously monitoring his weight and body composition.

In business there’s an expression: “What gets measured gets managed.” If you’re trying to reduce your weight and body-fat percentage, it only makes sense to measure these things regularly. The pros do, and research has shown that nonathlete dieters who weigh themselves often lose more weight than those who avoid the scale. I recommend that all endurance athletes weigh themselves at least once a week and use a body fat scale such as the Tanita Ironman to estimate their body-fat percentage once every four weeks.

Step 5: Time your nutrition

A naturally big guy who once tipped the scales at 200 pounds, professional triathlete T.J. Tollakson stays lean by frontloading his daily energy intake in accordance with the dictum “eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince, and dinner like a pauper.”

With respect to weight management, when you eat is almost as important as what you eat. The most important times of the day to eat are in the morning and within an hour after workouts because calories eaten at these times are less likely to be stored as fat and more likely to be incorporated into muscle tissue and used for immediate energy needs.

Step 6: Train for racing weight

Nearly all professional endurance athletes train by what’s known as the Lydiard method, which entails doing a high volume of training, about 80 percent of it at low intensities, 10 percent at moderate intensities, and 10 percent at high intensities.

While a low-volume, high-intensity approach to training has gained popularity among age-group endurance athletes lately, it is not the most effective way to train for endurance performance or achieve a lean body composition. Research provides clear support for the Lydiard method that is used almost universally by the elites.

Obviously, few age groupers have the time, energy, or durability to train as much as the pros do, but that’s not the point. The point is to maintain a training volume that is close to your personal limit and to keep the intensity low for four out of every five workouts. If you do this you will burn far more calories and build greater aerobic fitness than you possibly could by doing the small volume of training you can handle if you go hard (or even moderately hard, as a majority of age groupers do) in most workouts.

When it comes to training and eating to attain your optimal racing weight, the best thing to do is the same thing you do in races: follow the pros!

Racing Weight 2nd Ed. RW2 96dpi 400x600p strokeRacing Weight is a proven weight-management program for endurance athletes.